I found interesting article in judokaquaterly website about judo, mma.
http://judokaquarterly.com/2015/05/guilty-pleasures-judo-mma-and-ronda/
I found there very nice quotes:
In March, EJU president Sergey Soloveychick explained to the BBC why the EJU disapproved of the UFC: “MMA is not a sport, it is some kind of show…Sport should have some human values and sports should help society develop human values…It’s not good if your opponent is on his stomach and you sit on him and beat his head. It’s not good for the education of the young generation, so we don’t like to promote this kind of organization during our competition.”
Very nice conclusion:
If we are to follow the precepts of Kano who emphasized that judo is about personal cultivation leading one to become a better member of society (yes folks, that is the ultimate aim of “jitakyoei”) then we should look away. The “ground and pound” is not the height of civilization. It is far closer to the gladiator ring than the Olympic rings. It is barbarity and yet we still watch. In Rousey’s book she goes into a graphic explanation of how it feels to pop an opponent’s elbow socket. She glibly remarks, “Its like ripping the leg off a Thanksgiving turkey.” Her quote reminds me of something Mike Tyson once said: “I try to catch them right on the tip of his nose, because I try to punch the bone into the brain.” These are disturbing images, especially if we are to view either professional boxing or MMA as a sport. In light of this, the fact that Dana White, president of the UFC, cites Ronda Rousey as a role model for children in the foreword to her book is unsettling.
My sensei Yonezuka Yoshisada fought against boxers and wrestlers when he first came to the United States. He did it for money as he struggled to make ends meet while trying to establish his dojo in the early 1960’s. Despite this experience, he had this say about MMA, “All sports have some beauty in their own execution of technique; however I feel that today’s UFC and MMA fights are missing this kind of beauty.” (Martial Arts Masters Magazine, Summer 2010, p. 48)
Perhaps, as judoka, we should re-examine our relationship with our sport and what we hope to contribute towards it as well what we get out of it. Taking this into consideration, watching and supporting MMA or the UFC may run counter to our own personal development and that of judo. Watching someone continuing to perform an armbar beyond the point of no return should be upsetting and we should want to look away. If we don’t, or if we can’t, than maybe we have already lost that part of our humanity that Kano sought to develop through the practice of judo in the first place.
http://judokaquarterly.com/2015/05/guilty-pleasures-judo-mma-and-ronda/
I found there very nice quotes:
In March, EJU president Sergey Soloveychick explained to the BBC why the EJU disapproved of the UFC: “MMA is not a sport, it is some kind of show…Sport should have some human values and sports should help society develop human values…It’s not good if your opponent is on his stomach and you sit on him and beat his head. It’s not good for the education of the young generation, so we don’t like to promote this kind of organization during our competition.”
Very nice conclusion:
If we are to follow the precepts of Kano who emphasized that judo is about personal cultivation leading one to become a better member of society (yes folks, that is the ultimate aim of “jitakyoei”) then we should look away. The “ground and pound” is not the height of civilization. It is far closer to the gladiator ring than the Olympic rings. It is barbarity and yet we still watch. In Rousey’s book she goes into a graphic explanation of how it feels to pop an opponent’s elbow socket. She glibly remarks, “Its like ripping the leg off a Thanksgiving turkey.” Her quote reminds me of something Mike Tyson once said: “I try to catch them right on the tip of his nose, because I try to punch the bone into the brain.” These are disturbing images, especially if we are to view either professional boxing or MMA as a sport. In light of this, the fact that Dana White, president of the UFC, cites Ronda Rousey as a role model for children in the foreword to her book is unsettling.
My sensei Yonezuka Yoshisada fought against boxers and wrestlers when he first came to the United States. He did it for money as he struggled to make ends meet while trying to establish his dojo in the early 1960’s. Despite this experience, he had this say about MMA, “All sports have some beauty in their own execution of technique; however I feel that today’s UFC and MMA fights are missing this kind of beauty.” (Martial Arts Masters Magazine, Summer 2010, p. 48)
Perhaps, as judoka, we should re-examine our relationship with our sport and what we hope to contribute towards it as well what we get out of it. Taking this into consideration, watching and supporting MMA or the UFC may run counter to our own personal development and that of judo. Watching someone continuing to perform an armbar beyond the point of no return should be upsetting and we should want to look away. If we don’t, or if we can’t, than maybe we have already lost that part of our humanity that Kano sought to develop through the practice of judo in the first place.