Davaro wrote:
You get people that investigate, as if it were some or other grand fraud or something, people that claim to be a shodan. And then as you say, don't accept this shodan claim unless they are tested by the "home" NGB. As if shodan is the holy grail and to claim to be one, one is a God.
If I had to go to Japan, test for Shodan at a place other than the Kodokan, pass and return home - It would not be accepted.
"The Kodokan" ... the school that the founder ... errr ... founded. Recognized, mythologized, misunderstood. But accepted.
The problem is ... there are little Hitlers everywhere. They like checking for the sake of checking, checking, checking and a veto power over someone else is likely the one act that makes them feel powerful in a world that somehow refuses to see how wonderful they are. If we have a pulse and venture out from under our bedcovers we cannot help but run into people like this constantly ... and yes in judo they seem attracted to promotion boards and refereeing because goodness knows these folks really, really like the rules and making other people obey them.
But the other problem is that there are people out there "passing bad paper" so to speak, often for the same reasons of insecurity as the little clerks. "I practically have my x-dan, and I know more than most x+2 dan for sure, so I'll just modify this document and wear this belt because the actual ones were so UNFAIRLY withheld from me and my wonderfulness."
On occasion there are ... and I know at least a couple of very severe cases ... the sociopaths who get into judo as a way of seeking victims ... financial, sexual, etc. Sometimes quite a bit of overlap with the above I might add. Just witness what occurred recently in Santa Barbara.
THEN ... coming back to judo ... there are the victims of the second and third group whose bad paper is once removed.
So after a while in this weird lifestyle we call judo one runs into these guys ... and they are usually emotionally microphallic guys ... and sometimes we are asked what should be done, where they should be placed in terms of responsibility and resource.
At that moment reliable references are necessary. And an NGB, or a recognizable non-NGB national organization, or the Kodokan are at least known quantities, one knows what those groups are up to and the approximate amount of hanky-panky one should look out for. Better than "I got my shodan from Master Guido Sarducci at the Red Dragon dojo in Lenore, North Carolina ... and he didn't believe in national registration because ... (see 1,2 and 3 above)." Time to check if that guy even can fall correctly, much less letting him loose in randori ... for his own safety.
It seems to me that the objective should not to be to tear down organizations for their imperfections ... because we are butt-sore from our encounters with them ... but to work to make rank credible, and simultaneously to widen our understanding of what other organizations require for rank ... and to really think about what is important when judging those standards in our own local organizations.
P.S. - one can get a Kodokan rank card from many dojo in Japan besides da big house upstairs from Kasuga Station.