OldeEnglishD wrote:Hi all,
For Tsuri-Komi-Goshi if you have your left hand gripping the right sleeve of your opponent, where do you prefer your right hand grip be? Lapel? I have found that if I can get a double sleeve grip the throw seems to work better. Has anyone else found this to be true? I will look for some videos of both methods if I can find them.
Hiya,
This is not a simple question, few questions are lol.
There is the definitive gokyo waza (Kodokan) that is with little variation rather written in stone. There are then adaptions on a theme or henka waza. Further to this some famous dojo like Tenri had a very distinctive 'style' of grip, the collar grip was high and would almost knock you out with a punching style of attack against ones jaw. Tokai also had a certain manner of fighting as did many of the police and private honbu dojo in Japan.
Both my sensei taught ogoshi holding around the neck not the waste as the canonical style of kodokan judo. They where both Busen staff and teachers at the pre WW11 DNBK.
For exams and in learning it is often of value to learn a
classic , hon, manner there are valuable reasons for this. After time one will develop ones own style even style on the style of a given dojo!
The thing to maintain is efficiency and preservation of energy while achieving maximum efficiency. I have some very very unorthodox grips for my o soto gari, more, I have numerous grips for numerous occasions.
In the waza in question it is wise to look at what the hands, hips and feet do. An awful lot of information regarding this waza is given in the name. Tsuri....Komi...Goshi. We know from the koshi reference that this is a koshi waza not a te or ashi waza so an awful lot of emphasis needs to be placed on the action and location of the hips. If we then take into consideration the tsuri and komi components we can see we are 'fishing' so need to get our trunk out of the way or we will fail due to the fact we will be making that trsuri komi action against our own body. To prevent this we need to drop our COG so our hips, as Heikojr has written, are as low as possible at least coming into contact with the lower thighs of uke.
Now to slightly complicate things (and why not, lol) you have described 'sode' as the manner of achieving the tsuri komi. Again one canonical manner (sode is not truly a separate waza but a henka of the basic waza, however) yet numerous henka and this is exactly as it should be. So I am unsure if your question has a single answer... Your judo, after learning the basics, should be unique to you and change according to who you are fighting and even your mood on the day.
Exams where the go kyo are requested is a different subject altogether.
I hope I have not confused you too much. Judo is by nature, rather complex.
Regards,
Mike
I suggest you simply enjoy randori and try as many grips and entries as you can think of.