Recently at the EJU Symposium in Montpellier one study presented some interesting findings. The researchers had obtained responses from 10 different groups of people involved in judo. There were judo teachers among them, PE teachers who practised judo, 1st year sports students-judoka, 1st year human sciences students-judoka, children judoka, regional level competitive judoka, and elite judoka. Responses were received from a total of 963 respondents.
Options ranged from the most important thing in judo for them being:
- winning medals
- winning combats,
- being fit
- obtaining belts,
-learning self-defense
and also the whole shebang of respect-related stuff.
The responses were interesting. Most judoka said that winning medals came last for them ... except the judo elite who put winning medals first ... obviously, I guess. Winning combats for them was an obvious second choice.
Intriguing thought that regional level competitive judo found winning combats the second most important thing but winning medals only the 5th important thing. Perhaps they have little choice and it is inherent to the fact that they are 'only' regional competitors and not the elite. In other words ... they can't win the medals because the elite will.
No person put obtaining belts very high in their choices, but then again ... we all know nobody in judo cares anything about belts and dan-ranks, now don't we ?
I wondered why about all the kids chose learning to defend themselves as the most important. Do they feel a need to be able to defend themselves ? I mean do they feel scared in an angry world, bullied or worse ? It's an interesting result that deserves further discussion.
Learning to respect each other is the first motivator in judoka who are also 1st year human sciences majors, yet learning to respect each other is about the least important thing in the national elite judoka and the same in the regional competitive level judoka. Need we say more ? It's not us disgruntled dinosaurs complaining, the judoka themselves made perfectly clear what they seek in judo, and the results are very much line with the concerns previously expect.
The only problem, admittedly, is that this is a recording in time. We cannot speculate about the evolution of those ideals. After all, it is likely that the national elite judoka in 30 years no longer will put winning medals as their first choice since they will then be the dinosaurs we are. But then again if they provide a response at that time they are no longer part of the nationale elite and their responses likely would be recorded in a different category. So in the end it is possible that obsession with competitive results at young age still leads emphasizing judo values at later age. That is something the study unfortunately can't answer.
Interesting work though. I wanted to give credit to the authors, but unfortunately I did not record their names in my notes and I can't remember who they were. An abstract of their work is due to appear later these year in the symposium proceedings to be published by the Archives of Budo." />