Home
So is CK arguing that NYCNewbie's throw is a renzoku waza of daki-wakare + ura nage while Ben and judoratt seem to think it's ura nage? Genetic judoka thinks it's ushiro something. We have quite a difference of opinions here...
+18
hedgehogey
Taiobroshi
Ricebale
Okazi
Cichorei Kano
genetic judoka
Blacksmith
medo
Wandering WB
judoratt
Ben Reinhardt
Jonesy
Udon
Ro
judo66
charlietuna
still learning
NYCNewbie
22 posters
What throw is this?
Wandering WB- Posts : 102
Join date : 2013-02-21
medo- Posts : 276
Join date : 2012-12-31
Wandering WB wrote:So is CK arguing that NYCNewbie's throw is a renzoku waza of daki-wakare + ura nage while Ben and judoratt seem to think it's ura nage? Genetic judoka thinks it's ushiro something. We have quite a difference of opinions here...
Ohh dear.....
Going going gone. I enjoy reading forums and occasionally participating I find I'm not enjoying it any longer I will retire. Good Luck young man......
I hope some of my responses were of use to some...
Mod please remove me from the Log list I no longer wish to participate.
Wandering WB- Posts : 102
Join date : 2013-02-21
Medo, please, what have I done wrong? I like arguing with you.
I am sorry if I have summed up the view points inaccurately. Somebody also mentioned Ko Soto Gama, genetic claims it's leg assisted Ushiro Goshi, while I still think that the throw consists of both hip and foot motion, with the foot motion being similar to STKA.
I am sorry if I have summed up the view points inaccurately. Somebody also mentioned Ko Soto Gama, genetic claims it's leg assisted Ushiro Goshi, while I still think that the throw consists of both hip and foot motion, with the foot motion being similar to STKA.
hedgehogey- Posts : 103
Join date : 2012-12-30
Out of all the things WWB said, that is what makes you flounce?
judoratt- Posts : 309
Join date : 2012-12-30
Age : 66
Location : Seattle
What I see as the bigest problem is everyone thinks too much relax call it what you want. I say ura nage and as I have said before " I am right almost half of the time" 
BTW KISS Keep It Simple Stupid
BTW KISS Keep It Simple Stupid
Cichorei Kano- Posts : 1948
Join date : 2013-01-16
Age : 863
Location : the Holy See
Wandering WB wrote:So is CK arguing that NYCNewbie's throw is a renzoku waza of daki-wakare + ura nage while Ben and judoratt seem to think it's ura nage? Genetic judoka thinks it's ushiro something. We have quite a difference of opinions here...
Not "daki-wakare + ura-nage", but "ura-nage + daki-wakare" while several of the clips were direct daki-wakare. The chief movement or the scoring throw was each time daki-wakare, since even if preceded by ura-nage, it was never ura-nage in the end, so the scoring throw was still daki-wakare in either case, that is the 'standing henka (variation)' of daki-wakare. A description of the technique can be found here (sorry, it's in Japanese, but at least one of the pages contains a pretty clear drawing; one of the pages refers to Daigo as sources; he is right):
http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/抱分
http://www.judo-ch.jp/dictionary/technique/nage/yoko/dakiwakare/
_________________
"The world is a republic of mediocrities, and always was." (Thomas Carlyle)
"Nothing is as approved as mediocrity, the majority has established it and it fixes it fangs on whatever gets beyond it either way." (Blaise Pascal)
"Quand on essaie, c'est difficile. Quand on n'essaie pas, c'est impossible" (Guess Who ?)
"I am never wrong. Once I thought I was, and that was a mistake."
Wandering WB- Posts : 102
Join date : 2013-02-21
Thanks, CK. Although I'd like to learn Japanese, I don't intend to become fluent tomorrow. I will check out the link at some point.
Ben Reinhardt- Posts : 794
Join date : 2012-12-28
Location : Bonners Ferry, Idaho, USA
medo wrote:Whats wrong with you lot, has no one read CK's extremely detailed description and answers of the OP's questions try from post 19.
Please am I the only one thinking here whats the point, I'm surrounded by white belts thinking there eighth Dans
I read it and appreciated it very much, I'd never have thought of Dake Wakare, but after the explanation I can see the point.
This is a place to discuss stuff, not have judgement passed down from on high from a burning bush.
medo- Posts : 276
Join date : 2012-12-31
Medo, please, what have I done wrong? I like arguing with you.
Out of all the things WWB said, that is what makes you flounce?
You will have to ask genetic judoka weird untruthful things going on behind the scenes.
This is a place to discuss stuff, not have judgement passed down from on high from a burning bush.
There’s discussing stuff then there’s the three wise monkeys syndrome.
God help the next generation of Judoka, if being taught by the up and coming WB’s of this world.
The burning bush says good bye…
Out of all the things WWB said, that is what makes you flounce?
You will have to ask genetic judoka weird untruthful things going on behind the scenes.
This is a place to discuss stuff, not have judgement passed down from on high from a burning bush.
There’s discussing stuff then there’s the three wise monkeys syndrome.
God help the next generation of Judoka, if being taught by the up and coming WB’s of this world.
The burning bush says good bye…
BillC- Posts : 806
Join date : 2012-12-28
Location : Vista, California
Cue the Theremin ...
judoratt- Posts : 309
Join date : 2012-12-30
Age : 66
Location : Seattle
Wandering WB wrote:
judoratt
They may however, have a pretty loud horn for everyone to hear. I have not been doing this for ten years, so I think I may improve still, in terms of proficiency.Be creful kids most people I know that toot their horns have very little to toot about.
Speaking about tooting your horn, wasnt that you that promised to train and post a competition video about a year and a half ago? or am I mistaken?
Ricebale- Posts : 423
Join date : 2013-01-01
Location : Wollongong Australia
Ben Reinhardt wrote:medo wrote:Whats wrong with you lot, has no one read CK's extremely detailed description and answers of the OP's questions try from post 19.
Please am I the only one thinking here whats the point, I'm surrounded by white belts thinking there eighth Dans
I read it and appreciated it very much, I'd never have thought of Dake Wakare, but after the explanation I can see the point.
This is a place to discuss stuff, not have judgement passed down from on high from a burning bush.
The Dake Wakare was only obvious to me because I like the technique, I can see how most people would see ura nage though as the "ura nage" has become erroneously a catch all term for any suplex motion in judo imo.
Wandering WB- Posts : 102
Join date : 2013-02-21
judoratt
I've competed since then, I just don't feel like posting it. Especially given the reaction to other vids I posted.Speaking about tooting your horn, wasnt that you that promised to train and post a competition video about a year and a half ago? or am I mistaken?
judoratt- Posts : 309
Join date : 2012-12-30
Age : 66
Location : Seattle
Wandering WB wrote:judoratt
I've competed since then, I just don't feel like posting it. Especially given the reaction to other vids I posted.Speaking about tooting your horn, wasnt that you that promised to train and post a competition video about a year and a half ago? or am I mistaken?
Most like Tiabroshi genetic and others are treated prety well when they post videos.
Wandering WB- Posts : 102
Join date : 2013-02-21
judoratt
Well I wasn't treated well at all when I posted vids. I will post another video when I have something that I think is interesting to watch.Most like Tiabroshi genetic and others are treated prety well when they post videos.
JudoStu- Posts : 212
Join date : 2013-01-04
Age : 50
Location : UK
Wandering WB wrote:judoratt
Well I wasn't treated well at all when I posted vids. I will post another video when I have something that I think is interesting to watch.Most like Tiabroshi genetic and others are treated prety well when they post videos.
Can we assume that you haven't won any matches yet in competition?
If so it doesn't matter, you should post them anyway. You may get some tips from some of the more experianced Judoka's here that would help your competition Judo.
_________________
Judo is only gentle for the guy on top
Wandering WB- Posts : 102
Join date : 2013-02-21
You can assume whatever you want, since after all, I am just a humble white belt. I will post when I think I have something that's interesting for others to watch. I would appreciate tips and technical advice from forum members when I post it. Thanks, JudoStu.Can we assume that you haven't won any matches yet in competition?
If so it doesn't matter, you should post them anyway. You may get some tips from some of the more experianced Judoka's here that would help your competition Judo.
genetic judoka- Posts : 541
Join date : 2012-12-30
Age : 36
Location : Florida
why would people not treat you well when you post videos on here? surely it's not your attitude. after all you've been nothing but a beacon of politeness, respectfulness, humility, and willingness to listen to those who know more than you. surely it must be some deep seated jealousy of your self proclaimed superior grappling abilities.
_________________
Warning: I am very opinionated, and very willing to share that opinion. However I am very much aware that I am here as a student, not a teacher.
NYCNewbie- Posts : 69
Join date : 2012-12-29
genetic judoka wrote:why would people not treat you well when you post videos on here? surely it's not your attitude. after all you've been nothing but a beacon of politeness, respectfulness, humility, and willingness to listen to those who know more than you. surely it must be some deep seated jealousy of your self proclaimed superior grappling abilities.
It's true- WB- look inward, not outward. You are NOT an easy person to converse with on the web.
Your posts often lack humility- and it is always better to be too humble than not humble enough.
tafftaz- Posts : 330
Join date : 2012-12-31
Age : 58
Location : Wales, UK
In WB's defence, he has been a lot better lately than his earlier contributions to either forum.
As for posting videos,well I have videos of me competing at world masters/commonwealth/national champs but will not post them. I just have'nt got the guts to.
Even though I medalled in most of the videos I believe they are not a true representation of my judo. Shiai is a different animal to what you practise in a club enviroment.
So GJ I think WB really is trying to fit in. Give him a chance.
As for posting videos,well I have videos of me competing at world masters/commonwealth/national champs but will not post them. I just have'nt got the guts to.
Even though I medalled in most of the videos I believe they are not a true representation of my judo. Shiai is a different animal to what you practise in a club enviroment.
So GJ I think WB really is trying to fit in. Give him a chance.
Wandering WB- Posts : 102
Join date : 2013-02-21
Lol at all three of you. I'll get you a video as soon as I possibly can without starting a street fight.
tafftaz- Posts : 330
Join date : 2012-12-31
Age : 58
Location : Wales, UK
No need to post one on my account. I really do not care either way. I respect your decision not to post one.As I said earlier,personally I have'nt got the balls to post one. Some people like to get feedback or justification from their peers when postinmg videos,when the only feedback or justification that matters is between the judoka and his sensei,as they are the only ones who can improve the judokas judo. No amount of advice or critiscism on an internet forum will change that.
So if I made you "laugh out loud" with my post,at least I cheered you up for a bit.
So if I made you "laugh out loud" with my post,at least I cheered you up for a bit.
Wandering WB- Posts : 102
Join date : 2013-02-21
Well, at least one person gets it. Thank you.No need to post one on my account. I really do not care either way. I respect your decision not to post one.As I said earlier,personally I have'nt got the balls to post one. Some people like to get feedback or justification from their peers when postinmg videos,when the only feedback or justification that matters is between the judoka and his sensei,as they are the only ones who can improve the judokas judo. No amount of advice or critiscism on an internet forum will change that.
So if I made you "laugh out loud" with my post,at least I cheered you up for a bit.
sodo- Posts : 187
Join date : 2013-01-11
Location : Europe
tafftaz wrote:In WB's defence, he has been a lot better lately than his earlier contributions to either forum.
As for posting videos,well I have videos of me competing at world masters/commonwealth/national champs but will not post them. I just have'nt got the guts to.
Even though I medalled in most of the videos I believe they are not a true representation of my judo. Shiai is a different animal to what you practise in a club enviroment.
So GJ I think WB really is trying to fit in. Give him a chance.
atb
sodo
_________________
BillC- Posts : 806
Join date : 2012-12-28
Location : Vista, California
[quote="sodo"]
tafftaz wrote:
atb
sodo
|
|
|